← Back to Legends of Dance

Peter Gennaro

Legend of Dance

1910s

Why They Matter

Gennaro matters because his career makes visible how musical-theatre dance circulates between the ensemble performer, the featured dancer, the choreographer and the producer of mass entertainment. His West Side Story archive also provides a valuable case study in collaborative authorship and in the…

Styles Peter Gennaro shaped

Each one links to the style’s own page — its origins, music, tempo and video.

Biography

Peter Gennaro was born in Metairie, Louisiana, on November 23, 1919. A dancer, choreographer and teacher whose work spanned Broadway, television and large-scale entertainment staging, Gennaro built a career that made him one of mid-century musical theatre's most significant dance artists. He made his Broadway debut as a performer in *Make Mine Manhattan* in 1949, followed by roles in *Arms and the Girl* and the original production of *Guys and Dolls* in 1950. His visibility grew through featured performances in *The Pajama Game*, where he danced in Bob Fosse's iconic "Steam Heat" trio, and *Bells Are Ringing*, where he played Carl and partnered Judy Holliday in "Mu Cha Cha."

Gennaro's most significant credit came with the original 1957 Broadway production of *West Side Story*, where he received official co-choreography credit alongside Jerome Robbins. Archival documentation held at the New York Public Library—including contracts, photographs and oral histories—reveals that this collaboration was more complex than conventional accounts suggest, though the precise division of labor across specific numbers requires direct archival evidence rather than assumption.

Following *West Side Story*, Gennaro established a prolific career as a principal Broadway choreographer and musical-staging director. His credits included *Fiorello!*, *The Unsinkable Molly Brown*, *Mr. President*, *Bajour* and the 1973 revival of *Irene*, earning multiple Tony nominations for these productions. His most celebrated solo achievement came in 1977 when he won the Tony Award for choreographing the original Broadway production of *Annie*. He later received another Tony nomination for choreographing the 1982 revival of *Little Me*. Beyond Broadway, Gennaro's work extended to television variety programming and Radio City Music Hall.

Gennaro died at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York City on September 28, 2000, at age 80. His archive at the New York Public Library preserves the record of a career that cannot be reduced to a single show—one that linked the embodied knowledge of a Broadway performer with the craft of choreographing character, rhythm and story for stage and screen.

Career Highlights

1949

Made his Broadway debut in Make Mine Manhattan as a performer. IBDB

1950

Appeared on Broadway in Arms and the Girl and the original production of Guys and Dolls. IBDB

1954

Performed in The Pajama Game, including Bob Fosse’s “Steam Heat” trio. IBDB

1956

Played Carl in Bells Are Ringing and partnered Judy Holliday in “Mu Cha Cha.” IBDB

1957

Received official co-choreography credit for the original Broadway production of West Side Story. NYPL exhibition

1959

Choreographed Fiorello!, earning a 1960 Tony nomination. IBDB

1960

Choreographed the original Broadway production of The Unsinkable Molly Brown. IBDB

1962

Choreographed Mr. President. IBDB

1964

Staged the musical numbers for Bajour and received a Tony nomination. IBDB

1973

Provided musical staging for the Broadway revival of Irene and received a Tony nomination. IBDB

1977

Won the Tony Award for choreographing the original Broadway production of Annie. Tony Awards

1982

Choreographed the Broadway revival of Little Me and received a Tony nomination. IBDB

Legacy & Impact

Gennaro's importance lies in how his career illuminates the often-obscured pathways between ensemble performer, featured dancer, choreographer and entertainment producer. His *West Side Story* collaboration offers a rare archival case study in shared creative labor and the ways Broadway credit can conceal the complexity of authorship. The Tony-winning clarity of his *Annie* choreography, paired with his range across dramatic and lyrical storytelling, demonstrates a choreographic voice that adapted to varied theatrical needs without sacrificing distinctive movement logic.

Explore More Legends

Discover the dancers, teachers, choreographers, and cultural icons who shaped how the world moves.

Keep the thread going

Dance history, technique, and the occasional rabbit hole — in your inbox. Thoughtful, infrequent, unsubscribe anytime.

Free. No spam. One click to leave.